In all disciplines there is disagreement about how science applies to real life problems and policy. This assignment asks you to analyse different expert perspectives on a real world issue, synthesise the arguments and discuss how similar disputes arise in your discipline area.

RES5115 Assignment 1 €“ Core Unit

Task: In all disciplines there is disagreement about how science applies to real life problems and policy. This assignment asks you to analyse different expert perspectives on a real world issue, synthesise the arguments and discuss how similar disputes arise in your discipline area.

1. Analyse each article separately, including an argument map for each article (diagram plus one paragraph each).

2. Outline objections to the arguments in each article and identify any objections or false arguments.(max 200 words each).

3. Synthesise the arguments in the three articles and draw conclusions about which position you found most convincing, providing your reasons.(max 400 words)

4. Outline a topic in your discipline where experts disagree, explain the different positions clearly, synthesise the arguments to argue for your position. (Max 500 words)

Table 1: Marking key

Marks Marker’s comments on your assignment

1a. Argument map for Article 1 and briefly explain the types of argument used (types of inductive/deductive). /10

1b. Argument map for Article 2 and briefly explain the types of argument used (types of inductive/deductive). /10

1c. Argument map for Article 3 and briefly explain the types of argument used (types of inductive/deductive). /10

2a. Review article 1 for its acceptability, sufficiency and relevance, and identify fallacies and/or possible objections /10

2b. Review article 2 for its acceptability, sufficiency and relevance, and identify fallacies and/or possible objections /10

2c. Review article 3 for its acceptability, sufficiency and relevance, and identify fallacies and/or possible objections /10

3. Synthesise the arguments presented in the three articles and outline your conclusion /10

4a Outline a topic where there is disagreement in your discipline /10

4b Briefly explain in ordinary language the different positions in your discipline /10

4c. Explain your reasons for the position you take /10

Referencing (all parts): appropriate and consistent usage throughout Marks may be deducted for incorrect referencing

Fluency of expression and grammatical correctness Errors may result in lost marks