I. Describe why the topic is important or what drew you to the topic in the opening paragraph.
II. Summarize the contents for two-three paragraphs — in your own words, of course.
III. Explain the author’s particular angle for two paragraphs (read reviews to help in this portion). What is the author’s thesis? Do you find the author’s argument convincing? What sort of biases does the author bring to the table? In this part of the review, use some direct quotes with page numbers in parenthesis (p1), unless you’re using a Kindle. Do a little research on the author. It’s worth noting, for instance, that Fawn Brodie — the author or a biography of Joseph Smith — is a lapsed Mormon. That’s an extreme case, but each author has an ax to grind. Why did he or she write the book?
IV. Analyze how well the author employs primary source evidence and other secondary sources in marshaling his or her argument.
V. Finally, conclude with how well you liked or disliked the book and why in the last paragraph. Would you recommend it? How did it change your view of the subject or your view of history?