JOURNAL REVIEW GRADING RUBRIC
Student:
Criterion Points Possible Points Earned Instructor Comments
Article Selection
Article pertains to a specific differentiated instruction strategy. 5
Article is no more than 5-years-old and comes from a scholarly journal. 5
Summary
• Main points of the article are summarized and the author’s qualifications are discussed.
• The chosen strategy is summarized clearly. 10
Critique
The paper displays a well-developed and informed critique of the chosen strategy. 10
Grammar & Spelling
Grammatically correct and clear. No spelling errors. 10
APA Style
Double-spaced, 12-pt. Times New Roman font with 1” margins. 2.5
2-3 pages. 5
The citation has a complete reference on the Reference Page in correct APA format. 2.5
Total /50

JOURNAL REVIEW GRADING RUBRIC
Student:
Criterion Points Possible Points Earned Instructor Comments
Article Selection
Article pertains to a specific differentiated instruction strategy. 5
Article is no more than 5-years-old and comes from a scholarly journal. 5
Summary
• Main points of the article are summarized and the author’s qualifications are discussed.
• The chosen strategy is summarized clearly. 10
Critique
The paper displays a well-developed and informed critique of the chosen strategy. 10
Grammar & Spelling
Grammatically correct and clear. No spelling errors. 10
APA Style
Double-spaced, 12-pt. Times New Roman font with 1” margins. 2.5
2-3 pages. 5
The citation has a complete reference on the Reference Page in correct APA format. 2.5
Total /50

JOURNAL REVIEW GRADING RUBRIC
Student:
Criterion Points Possible Points Earned Instructor Comments
Article Selection
Article pertains to a specific differentiated instruction strategy. 5
Article is no more than 5-years-old and comes from a scholarly journal. 5
Summary
• Main points of the article are summarized and the author’s qualifications are discussed.
• The chosen strategy is summarized clearly. 10
Critique
The paper displays a well-developed and informed critique of the chosen strategy. 10
Grammar & Spelling
Grammatically correct and clear. No spelling errors. 10
APA Style
Double-spaced, 12-pt. Times New Roman font with 1” margins. 2.5
2-3 pages. 5
The citation has a complete reference on the Reference Page in correct APA format. 2.5
Total /50