Compartive Critique

Paper instructions:

•    Comparative Critique of 7 Articles
You are required to review a minimum of seven articles which describe the public relations role of school leaders. You may use a maximum of three articles from Munro,  Roundtable Viewpoints:  Educational Leadership, but the remaining four must be found through your own research. You must write a single essay that compares and contrasts the elements of the seven articles. You will include a reference page, in APA format, that lists the seven articles used for this assignment. This essay should be 5–7 pages in length.
This assignment is due by 1:00 p.m. (ET) on Friday, August  29,2014.
Article 2.1: Stop Making Plans: Start Making Decisions; Michaeal C. Mankins and Richard Steele.
Article 3.3: Educational Leaders as Caring Teachers; Nel Noddings
Article 7.3:  The Ripple Effect; Andy Hargreaves and Dean Fink

COMPARATIVE CRITIQUE OF 7 ARTICLES GRADING RUBRIC
Criterion    Points Possible    Points
Earned    Instructor Comments
The purpose of each article is clearly and correctly identified.     20
Compares and contrasts the elements of the 7 articles.    25
•    All articles are about the public relations role of school leaders
•    No more than 3 articles are from the textbook reading.    10
The strengths of the article are properly assessed.    15
The weaknesses of the article are properly assessed.    15
You have concluded your critique with a summary statement on the overall effectiveness of each of the articles.    15
You provided the reference page listing the 7 articles reviewed.    5
All citations are in correct APA formatting.    10
Written in a scholarly manner (i.e. complete sentences, correct grammar and punctuation).    5